
23 Jun The Genesis of Shell – Part 2 of 2
[Continued from Part 1 ]
Royal Dutch
Three weeks later, as the Murex cruised down the Malacca Strait toward Singapore, its crew might have seen a flare on the Sumatran coast. Twelve years earlier, a Dutch tobacco farmer wandering around the area looking for suitable farmland stumbled across oil seeps. Aeilko Jans Zijlker had nothing but determination. It took him four years to secure a concession from the Sultan of Langkat and another year to raise sufficient money to drill a primitive well, which produced crude oil in commercial quantities. Five years later, the field at Pangkalan Brandan was turning a nice profit, so in September 1889, he boarded a steamer for Amsterdam with a view to securing funding for expansion.
Just as a sea voyage had transformed Robert Nobel’s fortunes seventeen years earlier, so too did Zijlker’s. A fellow passenger, Dr Norbertus van den Berg, was homeward bound to take up the post of governor of the Netherlands Bank. By the time they reached Amsterdam, van den Berg was a believer. Not only did he help Zijlker assemble a prospectus, he also secured King William III’s royal warrant and accepted the role of chairman of the board. So, when the “Royal Dutch Petroleum Company” was launched on the Amsterdam Stock Exchange in June 1890, it was oversubscribed fourfold. Zijlker’s return voyage was not so fortunate – he died in Singapore. His replacement, Jean Baptiste August Kessler, did not arrive in Pangkalan Brandan for another year. By then, two years after Zijlker’s departure, the site was a shambles.
Annual rainfall in Pangkalan Brandan is over 2 metres, and there is no such thing as a dry season. A railway built to transport crude oil from the well site to a new refinery was sinking in mud. Kessler was not an engineer but knew the solution was a pipeline. As a retired pipeline engineer and having spent some time in that area, I can only imagine how difficult it must have been stringing ten kilometres of threaded-joint pipe, piece by piece, through that jungle. But a gang of Dutchmen, Americans and Chinese coolies, who could barely understand each other, did it, and in February 1892 the refinery was commissioned. The kerosene fraction was 35%. It would be another two years before Karl Benz started mass producing cars with internal combustion engines, so the rest, including the gasoline, was waste. It was dumped in an adjacent disused quarry and flared. This was the flare those onboard the Murex might have seen as it sailed past six months later.
Meanwhile in Singapore, Samuel’s agents, Syme & Co, had established a 35,000- barrel capacity tank farm on Pulau Bukom, a 360-acre island 11 kilometres south-west of Boat Quay. The plan had been so thorough that Samuel had even sent a cargo of tinplate to the Far East, so small factories at each of his destinations could commence the fabrication of kerosene cans. These were painted in the red we associate with Shell to this day. Having discharged half its cargo at Pulau Bukom on 16 September 1892, the Murex continued on to Bangkok. The assault on Standard Oil’s monopoly in Asia had begun. Within 18 months Samuel & Co had launched ten more ships, all named after seashells, Conch, Clam, Elax, Bullmouth, Cowrie, etc. Their grip on the trade was such that ten years later, of all the oil to pass though the Suez, 90 per cent belonged to Samuel and his Tanker Syndicate.
Royal Dutch did not launch as robustly as the Tanker Syndicate but was given a leg up when the Dutch Colonial Government excluded foreign competition from its ports in the East Indies. By 1895 transportation costs had prevailed. Batumi to Singapore via Suez, 6,500 miles. Philadelphia to Singapore via the Cape, 12,600 miles. Shell’s red cans and Royal Dutch’s yellow cans replaced Standard’s blue cans in the Orient. Standard even feared Russian kerosene might compete in America, so reduced local prices in a pre-emptive move. A worldwide crude oil market had been established.
By 1897, Kessler was producing over 1,000 barrels of kerosene a day, and Royal Dutch was paying a 50% dividend and trading at nine times the issue price. Rockefeller was not happy, and takeover attempts were made, but patriotic fervour and the share price kept the predator at bay. However, near death was just around the corner. The Pangkalan Brandan wells began producing water. Although Kessler didn’t know it at the time, it was the beginning of the end of the reservoir. It was a phenomenon the Americans had come to understand well, and as the rumours spread the shares were dumped. To prevent a takeover, Royal Dutch issued special preference shares. But there was no point saving an oil company without oil.
A frantic drilling programme close to the existing wells at Pangkalan Brandan produced nothing. The rationale for this effort was convention. Hitherto, oil had been discovered in the vicinity of oil seeps; however, an emerging theory suggested crude oil was the product of the organic decay that remained trapped in domes formed at the high points of folded rock layers deformed by movement of the Earth’s crust. Geologists referred to these folds as anticlines. The “anticline” theory was first suggested in 1855 by an English geologist working in Burma. More recently, geologists, Dr C Porro, an Italian, and Dr C Schmidt, a Swiss, had been successful in applying this theory mapping crude oil prospects in Alsace and Romania. In a last throw of the dice, Kessler employed them to produce a geological map of North Sumatra and to identify likely drilling prospects.
Despite the best efforts of tigers, mosquitos and rain – as much as 4.5 metres a year in parts – their first report appeared in April 1889. It was a masterpiece and for years provided a basis for scientific exploration. It confirmed the reservoir at Pangkalan Brandan was in an anticline, but it had been depleted, and 100 dry wells drilled in the vicinity had made that abundantly clear. Drs Porro and Schmidt had mapped another promising structure and identified a drilling target at Peureulak, 100 kilometres to the north. It took eight months of patient diplomacy with the feisty Achinese. However, two weeks after securing a concession, the drilling crew was struggling to control a gusher. Two months later, barges were ferrying 4,000 barrels of crude a day to the refinery at Pangkalan Brandan. Crude oil exploration had become a science and Royal Dutch was back in business. Kessler had saved the company, but the effort killed him. He died in December 1900, just days short of his 47th birthday, but not before recommending his 34-year-old marketing manager, Henri Deterding, be appointed in his place.
Shell Transport and Trading
The years following the Murex’s maiden voyage had been altogether different for Marcus Samuel. By 1897 he had more than 15 tankers and carried 70% of the world’s seaborne petroleum trade. He was a trader rather than an oilman but knew that without reliable access to crude his ships would be worthless. His contract with the Rothschilds would expire in October 1900 and their relationship was strained. So, he badly needed alternative resources.
To that end, he teamed up with a manic Dutch expatriate who claimed to have found oil seeps in the jungle near Balikpapan. I have travelled the road north from there on many occasions and although I haven’t seen oil seeps, I have seen the exposed coal seams that burn on for weeks after bushfires have ignited them. I also know that, even in the 1970s, working in that jungle 1000 miles east of Singapore was a logistical nightmare. Nevertheless, against all the odds Samuel’s exploration team, led by his long suffering nephew, Mark Abrahams, struck crude oil in February 1897. It didn’t have a high kerosene fraction but towards the end of the century, as demand for automobile gasoline took off, so did the importance of this discovery.
Later in 1897, Marcus and his brother merged the Tanker Syndicate and its associated assets into the Shell Transport and Trading Company. This included the Balikpapan refinery now producing copious amounts of fuel oil. Within three years this fuel had replaced coal in the Shell fleet, thereby expanding the market for petroleum products even further. M Samuel & Co continued to prosper too. The brothers were winning both ways: eastbound kerosene shipments and the westbound commodity trade. Life couldn’t have been better for our portly champion. Well, yes it could.
It wasn’t an oil tanker that first threatened to block the Suez Canal, it was a Royal Navy battleship taking a shortcut to Shanghai. Strong winds blew it onto a sand bank off Port Said and it stuck. Inevitably, there was a Shell tanker nearby. Pectan was new and powerful and its patriotic owner was only too happy for it to go to the aid of an embarrassed Royal Navy. The 9,000-tonne tanker strained all ahead full for 24 hours before freeing the 15,000-tonne Victorious. Six months later, our 45-year-old hero from Houndsditch was knighted by a grateful Queen at Osborne House.
Sir Marcus was on a roll, but trouble was around the corner. Henri Deterding was a man on a mission. He now had a reliable source of crude in the Far East and was not about to leave that market to Sir Marcus. He also knew Shell’s Batumi deal was about to expire. He bought tankers, established rival depots in Shell strongholds and cut prices. This upset the Rothschilds, who had a stake in Sir Marcus’s fortunes. They asked Shady Lane to broker a peace accord, but the giant egos were irreconcilable.
The legendry gusher at Spindletop on 10 January 1901 tipped the balance in Sir Marcus’s favour. The well erupted at an estimated 75,000 barrels a day, doubling the entire American output. Guffey Petroleum, the successful wildcatter, knew better than to deal with Standard Oil but needed a buyer capable of moving large quantities. Shell was the obvious answer and Sir Marcus’s brother-in-law was sent to negotiate a deal. It was the “deal of the century” and was consummated in June. Shell agreed to take a minimum of 15 million barrels over 21 years at 25 cents a barrel.
Shell’s future seemed secure and in October, as Sir Marcus was losing patience with Deterding’s antics in the Far East, he boarded a steamer for New York for talks with Standard Oil. His goal was an alliance of equals, but Standard didn’t form alliances and they couldn’t agree on Shell’s value. He returned empty handed, or so he thought. Just before Christmas Standard offered Sir Marcus $40 million ($600 million today) for Shell, lock stock and barrel. It had been 11 years since he and Shady Lane had taken the Orient Express to Batumi.
Royal Dutch Shell
But Sir Marcus was a proud Englishman and not about to become a Standard Oil stooge. And why should he? – he had the deal of the century in his back pocket. But it wasn’t the deal of the century. Six months later, just as they had at Pangkalan Brandan, the wells at Spindletop ran to water. Overproduction had killed the golden goose. Sir Marcus now had more ships than he needed for the kerosene he was lifting from Batumi and Balikpapan. Following further pressure from Deterding and the Rothschilds, he agreed to the formation of the Asiatic Petroleum Company for the transportation and marketing of petroleum products east of the Suez. The company was formed in June 1902 with Shell, Royal Dutch and the Rothschilds as shareholders, Sir Marcus as chairman and Deterding as managing director.
Three months later, Sir Marcus was elected lord mayor of London. It was a fitting accolade for a man recognised as one of the city’s most successful entrepreneurs. He revelled in the trappings of office; however, the day-to-day functioning of Shell, so dependent on his presence, suffered. He had too many ships and not enough oil. Royal Dutch was paying a 60% dividend, Shell Transport and Trading, 5%.
The mutiny on the Potemkin in June 1905 signalled the end of Sir Marcus’s independence. The unrest spread to Baku where the oilfields were torched in the ethnic violence that followed. A young Joe Stalin, an Azerbaijani, was one of the ring leaders. Sir Marcus’s luck had run out; Balikpapan was not enough. He had no option but to agree to the formation of the Royal Dutch Shell Group, 60% Royal Dutch, 40% Shell Transport and Trading.
Our story ends when the union was finalised in 1908. It was a great blow to Sir Marcus’s ego, but Deterding was an astute and energetic administrator without peer. In the years following the union, Shell would have been vulnerable to a concentrated Standard Oil attack, but John Rockefeller had another problem. Teddy Roosevelt’s anti-trust campaign was gathering pace, and indeed in May 1911, Standard’s appeal against dissolution failed. By then Henri Deterding had gathered the reins and was taking the battle to Standard in California.
This was also the year Churchill was appointed First Lord of the Admiralty. His first meeting with Sir Marcus, arranged by Admiral Jackie Fisher, didn’t go well, but eventually he saw the sense in Sir Marcus’s argument for converting the Royal Navy from coal to fuel oil. Indeed, in August 1916, the Murex refuelled HMS Ark Royal off Gallipoli. Unfortunately, three months later, the brave pioneer was torpedoed off Alexandria with the loss of one seaman.
Sir Marcus remained as chairman of the combined companies and became an even wealthier man. In June 1922, he was elevated to First Viscount Bearsted. Five years later, he and his beloved Fanny died at home on the same day.
Postscripts
May 1911, Standard Oil’s appeal against dissolution failed. Standard Oil demerged. Rockefeller’s wealth doubled.
December 1911, Churchill appointed First Lord of the Admiralty.
August 1916, the Murex refuelled Ark Royal in Mudros Bay.
December 1916, the Murex torpedoed with one casualty.
May 1921, Royal Navy converted to 100% liquid fuel.
June 1922, Sir Marcus elevated to First Viscount Bearsted.
17 January 1927, Sir Marcus and Fanny died on the same day.
1965, M Samuel & Co and Philip Hill Higginson Erlanger’s merged to form Hill Samuel & Co UK.
December 1969, Macquarie Group founded as Hill Samuel & Co Australia.
1974, VLCC SPM mooring and 48” pipeline installed at Pulau Bukom. 60,000 bbl/hr unloading rate .
June 2005, Royal Dutch and Shell Transport and Trading merged to form Royal Dutch Shell following a reserves statement bungle that caused a scandal.
Bibliography
RJ Forbes & DR O’Beirne, The Technical Development of the Royal Dutch/Shell 1890–1940, EJ Brill, Leiden, 1957.
Royal Dutch Offer Document and Listing Particulars, Royal Dutch Shell PLC, 2005.
Peter Cabana, Energy Reality: What They Don’t Want You o Know, Archway Publishing, Bloomington, IN, 2017.
Peter Doran, Breaking Rockefeller: The Incredible Story of the Ambitious Rivals Who Toppled an Oil Empire Penguin Random House LLC, New York, 2016.
Sandy Franks & Sara Nunnally, Barbarians of Oil: How the World’s Oil Addiction Threatens Global Prosperity and Four Investments to Protect Your Wealth John Wiley & Sons Inc, Hoboken, NJ, 2011.
The Times, 6 February 1939, Sir Henri Deterding Obituary.
David Wilson graduated as a civil engineer from the University of Queensland in 1969. His professional life has been devoted to the design of offshore oil and gas production facilities in the Middle East and Far East.
Mr Andrew Maconie
Posted at 19:38h, 25 JuneAs always with all your narratives, this is most interesting. I did hear however that the Shell Brand was originally formed by a Dutch trader who used to go east to collect shells and then had the opportunity of exchanging shells for oil and thus one of the great LOGOS of the 20th century was created!
David Wilson
Posted at 19:29h, 27 JuneAndrew, The sea shell trader was Marcus Samuel’s father. He wasn’t Dutch. DW
Roz Wilson
Posted at 08:53h, 01 JulyGreat recount David! Thank you
John Vening
Posted at 01:30h, 23 AugustWilson D,
Well done – makes Anthony Sampson’s account in ‘The Seven Sisters’ almost turgid; which is not to criticise his books which are excellent (even although now somewhat dated) but lack a certain zest for expression – not unusual with economists!